Decision-making & Organization / Organization & Leadership

The “Keep the Humans” Premise Is What Stalls AI: Hand Admin Work to AI, Keep Only Executives Human

A business leader with a sharp gaze in a dark office. Headline: drop the premise of keeping humans

More companies are bringing in AI, yet many have barely changed how they are organized. They keep everyone where they are and add AI on top. Nobody's job changes, and not a single line of the org chart is redrawn.

My conclusion first: most companies adopt AI on the premise that the people stay. I believe that premise is the main reason AI adoption stalls. With it, AI never moves beyond being an assistant, because work is never rebuilt around what AI does best.

Put AI costs on the payroll line

Investor Jason Calacanis recently wrote on X that, by his own account, less than $40,000 a year in AI costs automated the work of seven full-time employees and created more than $2 million in value. Those are his numbers, and they will not be the same for every company. What caught my attention is what he compared the cost to.

Most companies file AI under software or communications. On that line, even a few hundred dollars a month feels expensive. But if AI is doing people's work, the right comparison is the payroll line. The question for a company president is not how much you pay for AI, but how many people's worth of work AI is carrying. Treat it as a tool expense and you end up minimizing it, giving AI small jobs, seeing small results, and concluding that AI is not worth much.

What worked: AI takes over admin, only executives stay human

What worked was replacing administrative work with AI and keeping humans only in the upper layer, the executives. Not admin staff using AI, but making the admin work itself AI's job. Once the work is AI's, the process can be rebuilt the way AI works best: document checks, routine exchanges, record keeping. It gets faster and less gets missed.

Executives keep the work of deciding what to do and what not to do, deciding which work AI takes and how far, and reviewing results to widen or narrow that scope. Relationships with customers and partners also stay with people. Humans decide, AI executes. The lines are clear, and that is far easier to run than a half-mixed setup.

What failed: keeping people in place and adding AI

What did not work was keeping admin staff, junior members and middle-level members in place while introducing AI. The organization became disjointed and AI use did not progress. Work got duplicated: people re-checked and hand-corrected what AI produced, or copied AI's records into another sheet. And nobody changed the process, so AI was forced to fit the old way of working. That is not a performance problem. It is a design problem.

The rule: design from what AI can do first

My rule in one line: start honestly from what AI can do. Do not start from what your current people can do. First see how far AI can go, then place people only where they are needed.

  1. Write the work out as steps, not by who does it: receive, check, record, return. Keeping names out separates feelings from structure.
  2. Test whether AI can do each step, using real material and a capable model. People make mistakes too, so compare on the same standard and hand AI the steps it does better.
  3. Place people only where they add meaning: major decisions, accountability, and customer relationships.

This is not about discarding people

I am not saying to let anyone go tomorrow. Before hiring, ask whether AI can do it. When someone leaves, ask whether the role can become AI's job before refilling it. Treat current employees with care, and still stop designing the company on the premise that people must stay. Small companies are especially suited to this, because the president can change the design tomorrow.

What to do this week

Put AI costs on the payroll line and look at how many people's worth of work AI carries. Pick one administrative task and write it out as steps rather than names. Then rebuild it starting from what AI can do. Drop the deep-rooted belief that people must always stay in the workplace, and a new shape for the company will come into view.

Full video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hcmdqnUUyJA